Catherine The Great Part 1

Catherine the Great.

by Simon Dixon

INTRODUCTION.

Jesus Christ, Napoleon and Richard Wagner are said to have inspired more biographies than any other figures in history. Catherine the Great cannot be far behind. Fascinated by a German princess who captured the Russian throne and corresponded with the leading minds of her age, her contemporaries started to tell her story from the moment she died on 6 November 1796. Ever since, her political achievements as ruler of the most powerful emergent empire in Europe have been set against rumours about the amorous liaisons on which she embarked in search of elusive personal fulfilment.

Over 200 years after the empress's death, when both aspects of her life still make headlines in Russia and the West, my aim has been to bridge the gap between formidable historical scholars.h.i.+p and the popular accounts that risk trivialising a woman whose life requires no embellishment to reveal its interest and importance. There is no need to invent her conversations: though her writings can rarely be taken at face value, they tell us much about her active mind. And there is no shortage of acute contemporary comment on her personality and reign (what posterity made of it is the subject of my final chapter). Unless otherwise acknowledged, translations from these sources are my own, though readers who want to explore for themselves now have access to a growing range of excellent English versions, listed in the Further reading section. In addition to identifying the sources of my quotations, the endnotes offer a further (if necessarily inadequate) guide to the scholars.h.i.+p on which I have drawn. A comprehensive list would fill a book far larger than this one.

The Russian historian and journalist Vasily Bilbasov made the same discovery at the end of the 1880s. In addition to filling a fat bibliographical volume, he took more than a thousand lively pages to cover only half of Catherine's life before the reigning tsar, Alexander III, intervened to prevent further revelations about his controversial predecessor. Since comprehensiveness is clearly an impossible goal, it is important to have a guiding purpose in choosing what to discuss and what to omit. In attempting to give a fully rounded portrait of the empress, I have taken a broadly chronological approach that helps to emphasise the very wide variety of problems with which an absolute monarch was confronted at any one time. (Corrections to generally accepted dates are largely silent, except where they significantly revise our understanding of the course of events, as, for example, in the case of the funerals of Empress Elizabeth and Alexander Lanskoy.) Above all, however, I have sought to recover a sense of place, situating Catherine in the context of the Court society in which she grew up in Germany and lived most of her long life in Russia. For all that she did to reshape the values of the Court of St Petersburg, it still preserved in the 1790s many of the features of the Baroque Courts which she had first experienced, at Stettin, Zerbst and Brunswick-Wolfenb.u.t.tel. Here the Court is understood in the multiplicity of senses familiar to her and her contemporaries: an inst.i.tution alive with intrigue extending from the monarch at its heart to the servants at its outer penumbra; a network of rival aristocratic clienteles at the centre of politics in much of Europe before the French Revolution; the symbolic authority to which foreign amba.s.sadors were accredited; an extraordinary range of palaces, both urban and surburban; and a glittering cultural icon representing the power and majesty of the ruler to her subjects, great and small. That was how Catherine experienced the Court. And no single event did more to reveal its kaleidoscopic significance than her coronation, with which my version of her story begins.

PROLOGUE.

THE CORONATION OF A USURPER 1762.

'Nowhere perhaps is the vicinity of a church more disagreeable than in Russia,' complained a Swedish prisoner of war in 1760, tormented by the 'perpetual dinging' from St Petersburg's Peter-Paul Cathedral.1 its bell tower was only a few feet from his cell. Yet had Count Johann Hrd been incarcerated in the moscow Kremlin, his ears would have been even sorer. While the Russians long continued to attribute magical powers to their bells, ringing them out to drive the devil from their parishes, their eighteenth-century rulers had co-opted the instrument as a symbol of the sacralisation of tsarist power. its bell tower was only a few feet from his cell. Yet had Count Johann Hrd been incarcerated in the moscow Kremlin, his ears would have been even sorer. While the Russians long continued to attribute magical powers to their bells, ringing them out to drive the devil from their parishes, their eighteenth-century rulers had co-opted the instrument as a symbol of the sacralisation of tsarist power.2 Empress Anna could think of no better way of adding to her glory in the 1730s than by commissioning the world's largest bell. Fatally cracked by fire in may 1737, before it had been raised from its casting pit, Empress Anna could think of no better way of adding to her glory in the 1730s than by commissioning the world's largest bell. Fatally cracked by fire in may 1737, before it had been raised from its casting pit, tsar-kolokol tsar-kolokol'the tsar bell'lay buried in the Kremlin until 1836, escaping the designs of an enterprising moscow freemason who planned to smelt it in the 1780s and use the metal for fonts to print a new children's Bible.3 But while Hrd was languis.h.i.+ng in the Peter-Paul Fortress, Empress Elizabeth had commissioned a rival instrument, almost as ma.s.sive, measuring more than forty feet in circ.u.mference. Alongside depictions of Christ, the Virgin mary and John the Baptist, the bell's founder Konstantin Slizov had adorned it with portraits of the imperial family. His inscription drove home the dedication: But while Hrd was languis.h.i.+ng in the Peter-Paul Fortress, Empress Elizabeth had commissioned a rival instrument, almost as ma.s.sive, measuring more than forty feet in circ.u.mference. Alongside depictions of Christ, the Virgin mary and John the Baptist, the bell's founder Konstantin Slizov had adorned it with portraits of the imperial family. His inscription drove home the dedication: In the year from the creation of the world 7268 and from the incarnation of G.o.d the Word 1760, this bell has been cast in moscow during the prosperous reign of the most Pious and most Autocratic Great Sovereign, Yelizaveta Petrovna, Empress of All Russia, in the 19th year of her reign and in the time of their Imperial Highnesses, the gracious Lord, Grand Duke Peter Fedorovich, and his consort, the gracious Lady, Grand d.u.c.h.ess YEKATERINA ALEKSEYEVNA, and in that of the gracious Lord [their son], Grand Duke PAVEL PETROVICH.4 By the time the bell was finished in 1762, the scene had radically changed. Elizabeth was dead; her successor, Peter III, overthrown and a.s.sa.s.sinated within six months of his accession. And so it was that on the morning of Sunday 22 September, Slizov's bell unexpectedly rang out for the first time to herald the coronation of Peter's widow, Yekaterina Alekseyevna, as Catherine II of Russia.

At the stroke of ten, a fanfare of trumpets and drums heralded the empress's ceremonial emergence from her private apartments in the Kremlin into the vaulted audience chamber of the Palace of Facets.5 She can hardly have had much sleep. Thousands of lesser bells had tolled from every church in the city at three in the morning for vespers and then again at six o'clock to call wors.h.i.+ppers to the vigil service that preceded Russian coronations. Two hours later, Slizov's 'great new bell' summoned the clergy to the Cathedral of the Dormition, emitting the 'deep hollow murmur' that a later visitor described, vibrating all over Moscow 'like the fullest and lowest tones of a vast organ, or the rolling of distant thunder'. She can hardly have had much sleep. Thousands of lesser bells had tolled from every church in the city at three in the morning for vespers and then again at six o'clock to call wors.h.i.+ppers to the vigil service that preceded Russian coronations. Two hours later, Slizov's 'great new bell' summoned the clergy to the Cathedral of the Dormition, emitting the 'deep hollow murmur' that a later visitor described, vibrating all over Moscow 'like the fullest and lowest tones of a vast organ, or the rolling of distant thunder'.6 The empress herself had been fasting in preparation for the coronation communion service and before she could make her public appearance there were still some intricate personal devotions to perform. In these she was guided by her confessor, archpriest Fedor (Dubyansky), who had grown so close to the pious Elizabeth that she conferred hereditary n.o.bility on all his children (he himself died in possession of some 8000 serfs). The empress herself had been fasting in preparation for the coronation communion service and before she could make her public appearance there were still some intricate personal devotions to perform. In these she was guided by her confessor, archpriest Fedor (Dubyansky), who had grown so close to the pious Elizabeth that she conferred hereditary n.o.bility on all his children (he himself died in possession of some 8000 serfs).7 But ritual observance was always a duty rather than a consolation to Catherine's sceptical mind, and she was less anxious about her prayers than about the need to present a suitably majestic image to her new subjects. Comforted by the servants who had taught her the Russian proverbs in which she took a childish delight, she set about composing herself for the ceremony that was to mark the ultimate stage in the transformation of an insignificant German princess, born Sophie Auguste Friderike of Anhalt-Zerbst on 21 April 1729, into 'the most serene and all-powerful Princess and lady, Catherine the Second, Empress and Autocrat of all the Russias'. But ritual observance was always a duty rather than a consolation to Catherine's sceptical mind, and she was less anxious about her prayers than about the need to present a suitably majestic image to her new subjects. Comforted by the servants who had taught her the Russian proverbs in which she took a childish delight, she set about composing herself for the ceremony that was to mark the ultimate stage in the transformation of an insignificant German princess, born Sophie Auguste Friderike of Anhalt-Zerbst on 21 April 1729, into 'the most serene and all-powerful Princess and lady, Catherine the Second, Empress and Autocrat of all the Russias'.

She had plenty of time to think while she dressed for the part. Catherine had spent at least 20,000 roubles on her wardrobe, almost half as much as the initial 50,000-rouble budget for the coronation itself (the final bill was for 86,000 roubles, though such was the variety of funds that supported this extraordinary event that the total costs may never be known).8 As a succession of startled subordinates had discovered in the brief interval since her accession on 28 June, no matter was too trivial to escape their new sovereign's attention to detail. Gone were the days of haphazard accounting under the profligate Elizabeth. Catherine, who valued precision above all else, always remembered what she had commissioned and always insisted on value for money. Her new coronation robea s.h.i.+mmering confection of silver brocade, trimmed with ermine and embossed with eagles and gold braidhad already been pored over for imperfections. Now it remained only to manoeuvre into place the bulky train that required seven gentlemen-in-waiting to carry it in her wake. The most senior was one of Russia's richest magnates, Count Peter Sheremetev, who had served the empress at her wedding banquet seventeen years earlier. As a succession of startled subordinates had discovered in the brief interval since her accession on 28 June, no matter was too trivial to escape their new sovereign's attention to detail. Gone were the days of haphazard accounting under the profligate Elizabeth. Catherine, who valued precision above all else, always remembered what she had commissioned and always insisted on value for money. Her new coronation robea s.h.i.+mmering confection of silver brocade, trimmed with ermine and embossed with eagles and gold braidhad already been pored over for imperfections. Now it remained only to manoeuvre into place the bulky train that required seven gentlemen-in-waiting to carry it in her wake. The most senior was one of Russia's richest magnates, Count Peter Sheremetev, who had served the empress at her wedding banquet seventeen years earlier.9 Only once she was satisfied that everything was secured was Catherine ready to face the world. Only once she was satisfied that everything was secured was Catherine ready to face the world.

Outside in the Kremlin's Ivanov Square, the four Guards regiments, summoned from their barracks by a 21-gun salute at 5 a.m., were already on parade, the colourful satins of their uniforms etched sharply against the pale stone walls of the three great Kremlin churches.10 Though these were all monuments to Muscovy's imperial pretensions in the reign of Ivan III (14621505), only the tsars' diminutive chapel royal, the Cathedral of the Annunciation, had been built by Russians. The Cathedral of the Archangel Michael, which preceded St Petersburg's Peter-Paul Cathedral as the royal necropolis, was the work of a Venetian architect. And it was a man from Bologna, Aristotele Fioravanti, who designed the most important church in Muscovy, the Cathedral of the Dormition, where the sixteen-year-old Ivan the Terrible had been the first to be crowned tsar in January 1547. Although the Muscovite coronation rite had been a single, standalone ceremony, Peter the Great had changed all that when he crowned his second wife, Catherine, in May 1724. Subsequent eighteenth-century coronations were followed by a week-long litany of receptions, b.a.l.l.s and firework displays and preceded by a triumphal 'entry' into the citya 'glorification of force' intended to show that the monarch's power derived as much from conquest as from consecration. Though these were all monuments to Muscovy's imperial pretensions in the reign of Ivan III (14621505), only the tsars' diminutive chapel royal, the Cathedral of the Annunciation, had been built by Russians. The Cathedral of the Archangel Michael, which preceded St Petersburg's Peter-Paul Cathedral as the royal necropolis, was the work of a Venetian architect. And it was a man from Bologna, Aristotele Fioravanti, who designed the most important church in Muscovy, the Cathedral of the Dormition, where the sixteen-year-old Ivan the Terrible had been the first to be crowned tsar in January 1547. Although the Muscovite coronation rite had been a single, standalone ceremony, Peter the Great had changed all that when he crowned his second wife, Catherine, in May 1724. Subsequent eighteenth-century coronations were followed by a week-long litany of receptions, b.a.l.l.s and firework displays and preceded by a triumphal 'entry' into the citya 'glorification of force' intended to show that the monarch's power derived as much from conquest as from consecration.11 However, since even this entry procession culminated in a service at the Cathedral of the Dormition, which was followed by a recessional to the remaining two cathedrals, However, since even this entry procession culminated in a service at the Cathedral of the Dormition, which was followed by a recessional to the remaining two cathedrals,12 Catherine's guardsmen had grown all too familiar with these hallowed buildings in the exhausting period of drills and rehearsals that had occupied them since the first detachments left St Petersburg on 4 August. They had scarcely been allowed to rest during the week of festivities and proclamations that had pa.s.sed since Catherine formally entered Moscow on Friday 13 September. As their sergeants barked a final series of commands to send each platoon to its post, the soldiery probably faced the great day itself with a mixture of antic.i.p.ation and relief. Catherine's guardsmen had grown all too familiar with these hallowed buildings in the exhausting period of drills and rehearsals that had occupied them since the first detachments left St Petersburg on 4 August. They had scarcely been allowed to rest during the week of festivities and proclamations that had pa.s.sed since Catherine formally entered Moscow on Friday 13 September. As their sergeants barked a final series of commands to send each platoon to its post, the soldiery probably faced the great day itself with a mixture of antic.i.p.ation and relief.

More complicated emotions affected some of their officers. Among the proud subalterns marshalling the Horse Guards into position was the newly promoted Second Lieutenant Grigory Potemkin, with whom Catherine was to fall in love in February 1774. She was probably betrothed to him in a secret ceremony sometime that summer, sharing with him not only a pa.s.sionate and very public affair, but also some of the most important decisions in the second half of her reign.13 For the moment, however, she remained committed to Grigory Orlov, a handsome hero of the Seven Years' War by whom she had given birth to an illegitimate son as recently as 11 April. While Potemkin pa.s.sed unnoticed among several young bucks who had pledged their allegiance to the new empress in return for lavish rewards, Orlov had been closely involved in the preparations for the coronation, taking a particular interest in arrangements made for the artists who had been commissioned to record the event for posterity. For the moment, however, she remained committed to Grigory Orlov, a handsome hero of the Seven Years' War by whom she had given birth to an illegitimate son as recently as 11 April. While Potemkin pa.s.sed unnoticed among several young bucks who had pledged their allegiance to the new empress in return for lavish rewards, Orlov had been closely involved in the preparations for the coronation, taking a particular interest in arrangements made for the artists who had been commissioned to record the event for posterity.14 Catherine was no less concerned with the reactions of a more immediate public. On top of the Kremlin ramparts, a separate troop of guardsmen wheeled into place the cannon that would proclaim crucial moments of the ceremony to an expectant crowd on Red Square. From that unpaved thoroughfare at the heart of the sprawling old capital, the throng spilled over into a maze of narrow lanes. Visiting in 1780, Joseph II of Austria found Moscow 'much larger than anything I've seen. Paris, Rome, Naples, in no way approach its size'.15 Two years earlier, the British traveller Archdeacon William c.o.xe declared it 'certainly the largest town in Europe, its circ.u.mference within the rampart...being exactly 39 versts or 26 miles'. Two years earlier, the British traveller Archdeacon William c.o.xe declared it 'certainly the largest town in Europe, its circ.u.mference within the rampart...being exactly 39 versts or 26 miles'.16 Though contemporary estimates of the city's population varied widely, and it fluctuated according to the season, as many as 300,000 people could cram into the city after the summer harvest. Though contemporary estimates of the city's population varied widely, and it fluctuated according to the season, as many as 300,000 people could cram into the city after the summer harvest.17 All of them, it seemed, had turned out to witness Catherine's triumphal entry nine days before the coronation. All of them, it seemed, had turned out to witness Catherine's triumphal entry nine days before the coronation.

Silken carpets, draped over the balconies of the grander houses, added a splash of semi-Asiatic colour to this most verdant of cities. Even the meanest streets through which the parade pa.s.sed were strewn with festive fir-branches, carved and formed into decorative trellises.18 Yet Moscow was by no means wholly synonymous with squalor. 'Some parts of this city have the look of a sequestered desert,' c.o.xe reported, 'other quarters of a populous town, some of a contemptible village, others of a great capital'. Yet Moscow was by no means wholly synonymous with squalor. 'Some parts of this city have the look of a sequestered desert,' c.o.xe reported, 'other quarters of a populous town, some of a contemptible village, others of a great capital'.19 Often dismissed as unplanned and unkempt by comparison with the geometrically regimented St Petersburg, the old capital could boast some impressive modern architecture of its own. The Kremlin a.r.s.enal, begun in 1702 but completed only in 1736, was an early example of Russian cla.s.sicism, the university (Russia's first, founded in 1755), one of the most recent at the time of Catherine's coronation. To these had been added four new triumphal arches, built by 3000 labourers under the supervision of architects working for Prince Nikita Trubetskoy's Coronation Commission. Often dismissed as unplanned and unkempt by comparison with the geometrically regimented St Petersburg, the old capital could boast some impressive modern architecture of its own. The Kremlin a.r.s.enal, begun in 1702 but completed only in 1736, was an early example of Russian cla.s.sicism, the university (Russia's first, founded in 1755), one of the most recent at the time of Catherine's coronation. To these had been added four new triumphal arches, built by 3000 labourers under the supervision of architects working for Prince Nikita Trubetskoy's Coronation Commission.20 Each arch featured two full-scale portraits of the empress by the Synodal artist Aleksey Antropov, and incorporated a mixture of cla.s.sical and panegyric motifs chosen by Trubetskoy's stepson Mikhail Kheraskov, the curator of Moscow University and one of the leading Russian writers of the age. Each arch featured two full-scale portraits of the empress by the Synodal artist Aleksey Antropov, and incorporated a mixture of cla.s.sical and panegyric motifs chosen by Trubetskoy's stepson Mikhail Kheraskov, the curator of Moscow University and one of the leading Russian writers of the age.21 Nor was it only the foreign elements in Russian culture that were mobilised to welcome the new sovereign. Priests bowed from the porches of every church in the city as a carillon rang out on the eve of the second great feast in the Orthodox liturgical calendar, the Exaltation of the Life-Giving Cross. Spectators who could find a ticket or bribe the guards mounted galleries erected in all the city's main squares to gain a better view of their empress as she swept past in an open eight-horse carriage through streets lined with cheering subjects on her way to the Nikolsky Gate. There, at the north-eastern corner of the Kremlin, Catherine was formally greeted by Metropolitan Timofey (Shcherbatsky), while a choir of students from Moscow's Slavonic-Greek-Latin Academy, dressed in white and holding forth laurel branches, hymned G.o.d's chosen ruler before accompanying her to a service of celebration at the Cathedral of the Dormition. 'Sing solemnly, Russia,' the seminarists chanted: 'raise your voice to the heavens.'22

Catherine's entry into Moscow could hardly have presented a more impressive spectacle. Behind the scenes, however, the government worried that an unprecedented influx of migrants might destabilise an already overcrowded city. The Court and all its acolytes had decamped en ma.s.se from St Petersburg, leaving the Earl of Buckinghams.h.i.+re, who arrived there as the new British amba.s.sador on 11 September, stranded without hope of reaching Moscow in time for the coronation (he had to be satisfied with the celebrations presided over by Ivan Neplyuev, the Senator left in charge of the capital in the empress's absence).23 Already softened by the autumn rains, the roads to the old capital were 'very bad, and the horses so much fatigued with the concourse of people who have lately travelled that way, as to make any degree of expedition impracticable'. Already softened by the autumn rains, the roads to the old capital were 'very bad, and the horses so much fatigued with the concourse of people who have lately travelled that way, as to make any degree of expedition impracticable'.24 Some 395 horses were required at each posting station merely to transport the 63 carriages needed by Catherine's small entourage of 23. Since the tsarevich's suite demanded 257 horses for 27 carriages, the Postal Chancellery took more than a month to a.s.semble the necessary animals. By one estimate, some 19,000 horses were hired to haul the remaining notables, the wheels of their carriages splas.h.i.+ng mud over the lines of straggling rustics, beggars and petty tradesmen who flocked to the old capital in the hope of sharing in the bounty traditionally distributed by a 'merciful' new monarch. In 1903, the contrast between richly attired courtiers and ragged peasants would wreck Nicholas II's quest for national reconciliation at the canonisation of St Serafim of Sarov. Anxious to avoid any such comparison during Catherine's coronation, her officials belatedly banned the import of fabric woven in gold and silver thread on 17 September. Some 395 horses were required at each posting station merely to transport the 63 carriages needed by Catherine's small entourage of 23. Since the tsarevich's suite demanded 257 horses for 27 carriages, the Postal Chancellery took more than a month to a.s.semble the necessary animals. By one estimate, some 19,000 horses were hired to haul the remaining notables, the wheels of their carriages splas.h.i.+ng mud over the lines of straggling rustics, beggars and petty tradesmen who flocked to the old capital in the hope of sharing in the bounty traditionally distributed by a 'merciful' new monarch. In 1903, the contrast between richly attired courtiers and ragged peasants would wreck Nicholas II's quest for national reconciliation at the canonisation of St Serafim of Sarov. Anxious to avoid any such comparison during Catherine's coronation, her officials belatedly banned the import of fabric woven in gold and silver thread on 17 September.25 Fears that speculators might cause unrest by artificially inflating bread prices proved unfounded. Though Moscow remained a paradise for petty criminals throughout the festivities, the mood among the crowds was jubilant from the moment that Catherine arrived in the city. On the eve of her coronation, thousands of men and women streamed towards the Kremlin, where those lucky enough to acquire tickets would be admitted the following morning to places reserved for the populace. Undeterred by forecasts of wind and rain, their less fortunate fellows clambered up onto neighbouring rooftops in the hope of catching a glimpse of their sovereign.26 In the event, the day dawned dry, if gloomy, and those intrepid enough to secure a vantage point did not have long to wait. The partic.i.p.ants in the coronation had been summoned to their various a.s.sembly points across the Kremlin at the same early hour as the soldiers,27 and at ten o'clock Prince Trubetskoy began to count out the elaborate procession that flowed slowly through the Holy Vestibule on the first floor of the Palace of Facets, out onto the ceremonial Red Staircase, and down into Cathedral Square. and at ten o'clock Prince Trubetskoy began to count out the elaborate procession that flowed slowly through the Holy Vestibule on the first floor of the Palace of Facets, out onto the ceremonial Red Staircase, and down into Cathedral Square.

Though Catherine would ultimately come to question the baroque extravagance of Elizabethan ceremonial, deeming cla.s.sical self-restraint better suited to a monarch who claimed to rule in the public interest, her initial aim was simply to outdo her predecessors by staging the grandest coronation in living memory. Whereas there had been twenty sections in Empress Anna's procession in 1730 and forty-two in Elizabeth's in 1742, Catherine's boasted no fewer than fiftyone.28 They represented a microcosm of Russia's multinational elite, const.i.tuting at once an impressive demonstration of political unity and an equally visible reminder of the various potentially conflicting interests that the empress would need to reconcile if she was to consolidate her position on the throne. They represented a microcosm of Russia's multinational elite, const.i.tuting at once an impressive demonstration of political unity and an equally visible reminder of the various potentially conflicting interests that the empress would need to reconcile if she was to consolidate her position on the throne.

Leading off down the Red Staircase, thirty Chevaliers Gardes, three abreast, were the first to set foot onto a specially erected wooden walkway '21 English feet wide' which stretched across Cathedral Square, its railings draped with colourful silks and carpets in the manner of its prototype in 1742.29 On reaching the Cathedral of the Dormition, the cavaliers fanned out on either side of its great south door to allow the thirty-one pages behind them to pa.s.s inside. Since there was no room for them during the coronation service, they processed straight out through the north door into the Synodal Palace to await the end of the ritual. On reaching the Cathedral of the Dormition, the cavaliers fanned out on either side of its great south door to allow the thirty-one pages behind them to pa.s.s inside. Since there was no room for them during the coronation service, they processed straight out through the north door into the Synodal Palace to await the end of the ritual.30 Behind them, two masters of ceremonies took up their positions near the throne of Monomakh, the tsar's place of wors.h.i.+p just inside the cathedral, ready to guide the main body of the procession to their places. Behind them, two masters of ceremonies took up their positions near the throne of Monomakh, the tsar's place of wors.h.i.+p just inside the cathedral, ready to guide the main body of the procession to their places.

First came representatives of Catherine's non-Russian subjects, headed by twenty-two townsmen from the Baltic lands and Russian Finland, territories conquered from Sweden by Peter the Great in the Great Northern War of 170021. Two Englishmen formed part of a seven-strong cohort of foreign-born merchants who had pledged their loyalty to the Russian monarchy: John Tames, a member of the linen manufacturing dynasty whose Dutch founder had been friendly with Tsar Peter, and Martin Butler, joint proprietor of a wallpaper business whose establishment of a privileged manufactory in Moscow in 1751 had provoked British rivals to protest to the Lords Commissioners for Trade.31 Even in their finest attire, such worthies must have cut a sober figure alongside the Zaporozhian and Don Cossack officers who followed them down the Red Staircase bedecked in strident colour. Next came four delegations from Little Russia (Ukraine), and nine German knights from Livland and Estland. Only then did Russians themselves join the procession, led by members of the twelve administrative Colleges established by Peter the Great as Russia's princ.i.p.al inst.i.tutions of central government. Seventeen groups of officials culminated in a delegation from the College of Foreign Affairs including the empress's influential secretary, Grigory Teplov. Behind them followed eight of the twenty-five members of the Senate, Russia's highest secular court and princ.i.p.al governing body, in the customary order of seniority, juniors first. Even in their finest attire, such worthies must have cut a sober figure alongside the Zaporozhian and Don Cossack officers who followed them down the Red Staircase bedecked in strident colour. Next came four delegations from Little Russia (Ukraine), and nine German knights from Livland and Estland. Only then did Russians themselves join the procession, led by members of the twelve administrative Colleges established by Peter the Great as Russia's princ.i.p.al inst.i.tutions of central government. Seventeen groups of officials culminated in a delegation from the College of Foreign Affairs including the empress's influential secretary, Grigory Teplov. Behind them followed eight of the twenty-five members of the Senate, Russia's highest secular court and princ.i.p.al governing body, in the customary order of seniority, juniors first.32 Once some of Catherine's closest allies had a.s.sumed their places in the procession, bearing the imperial regalia, the appearance at the top of the staircase of Prince Trubetskoy was the signal for the emergence of the empress herself.33 Beneath a silken canopy carried by nine senior officialsanother mark of the sacral status of the monarch, adopted from ecclesiastical processionscould be seen the unmistakeable silhouette of the woman who was soon to become the most celebrated monarch in Europe. Beneath a silken canopy carried by nine senior officialsanother mark of the sacral status of the monarch, adopted from ecclesiastical processionscould be seen the unmistakeable silhouette of the woman who was soon to become the most celebrated monarch in Europe.34 Already statuesque at the age of thirty-three, Catherine had never been blessed with conventional good looks. Admitting that her 'features were far from being so delicately and exactly formed as to compose what might pretend to regular beauty', Buckinghams.h.i.+re was too polite to single out her long, aquiline nose. At least it was compensated by 'a fine complexion, an animated and intelligent eye, a mouth agreeably turned, and a profusion of glossy chestnut hair', all of which combined to 'produce that sort of countenance which, a very few years ago, a man must have been either prejudiced or insensible to have beheld with indifference'. Already statuesque at the age of thirty-three, Catherine had never been blessed with conventional good looks. Admitting that her 'features were far from being so delicately and exactly formed as to compose what might pretend to regular beauty', Buckinghams.h.i.+re was too polite to single out her long, aquiline nose. At least it was compensated by 'a fine complexion, an animated and intelligent eye, a mouth agreeably turned, and a profusion of glossy chestnut hair', all of which combined to 'produce that sort of countenance which, a very few years ago, a man must have been either prejudiced or insensible to have beheld with indifference'.35 The overall effecta streak of masculinity running through her feminine formwould fascinate her contemporaries for the rest of her life. Catherine did nothing to dispel their puzzlement. Years of isolation at the Court of Empress Elizabeth had taught her never to reveal her innermost thoughts. The overall effecta streak of masculinity running through her feminine formwould fascinate her contemporaries for the rest of her life. Catherine did nothing to dispel their puzzlement. Years of isolation at the Court of Empress Elizabeth had taught her never to reveal her innermost thoughts.

Impa.s.sive as the empress seemed as she paused at the top of the Red Staircase, she might have been forgiven a moment of private trepidation. Catherine had first processed across Cathedral Square to commemorate her engagement to Grand Duke Peter shortly after her arrival in Russia in 1744, a ceremony she recalled with distaste. Scarcely less miserable was the memory of the extraordinary occasion in 1753 when Elizabeth had chosen to celebrate the eleventh anniversary of her own coronation by re-staging the ritual in every respect bar the placing of the crown on her head.36 For everyone except the empress, who moved into the Kremlin apartments on the eve of the ceremony, the proceedings proved tiresome in the extreme. Catherine and her husband had to travel in state from the draughty wooden palace on the Yauza River where the Court resided during its visits to Moscow, their servants trotting alongside the carriage for several miles. Neither did matters improve once the ceremony began. As Catherine later recalled: For everyone except the empress, who moved into the Kremlin apartments on the eve of the ceremony, the proceedings proved tiresome in the extreme. Catherine and her husband had to travel in state from the draughty wooden palace on the Yauza River where the Court resided during its visits to Moscow, their servants trotting alongside the carriage for several miles. Neither did matters improve once the ceremony began. As Catherine later recalled: It was as cold and damp in that church as I had ever felt in my life. I was blue all over and freezing cold in a Court dress open at the neck. The Empress told me to put on a sable stole but I had none with me. She had her own brought to her and took one, wrapping it round her neck. I saw another in her box and thought that she was going to give it to me to put on, but I was wrong. She sent it back. It seemed to me to be rather a clear sign of ill will.37 After the service, while Elizabeth dined alone in the Kremlin, Peter and Catherine returned to the suburbs in the pouring rainand in no better a temper than Elizabeth had displayed during the ceremony itself.

More sinister than any temporary discomfort were the wider cultural values represented by the old capital. Catherine instinctively disliked almost everything Moscow stood for. To a monarch obsessed by the value of time, the city merited condemnation as 'the seat of sloth'. Its very size was an obstacle to efficiency. 'When there,' she wrote later, 'I make it a rule not to send for anyone, since one never finds out until the following day whether the person will come or not and to pay a visit oneself is to waste a whole day in the carriage.' n.o.bles lived in Moscow 'in idleness and luxury', tended by too many 'useless domestic servants', and 'apart from that, nowhere do people have before their eyes so many symbols of fanaticism, miraculous icons at every step, churches, priests, and convents, side by side with thieves and brigands'.38 Since 'Moscow' signified many of the vices that Catherine would seek to extirpate from her Enlightened empire during her thirty-four years on the Russian throne, there was every reason for her to sympathise with the subjugation of the Muscovite past symbolised by her triumphal entry into the city. Since 'Moscow' signified many of the vices that Catherine would seek to extirpate from her Enlightened empire during her thirty-four years on the Russian throne, there was every reason for her to sympathise with the subjugation of the Muscovite past symbolised by her triumphal entry into the city.39 However, since she nevertheless acknowledged the old capital as the repository of a national heritage that she was determined (and committed) to defend, her decision to be crowned there, confirmed within ten days of her accession, suggests that she was equally anxious to mobilise the Kremlin's sacred historic a.s.sociations in support of her own precarious regime. However, since she nevertheless acknowledged the old capital as the repository of a national heritage that she was determined (and committed) to defend, her decision to be crowned there, confirmed within ten days of her accession, suggests that she was equally anxious to mobilise the Kremlin's sacred historic a.s.sociations in support of her own precarious regime.

So shaky were the foundations of Catherine's authority in September 1762 that it was by no means certain that she would reach the first anniversary of her accession. She owed her power to a conspiracy shared with Grigory Orlov and a handful of fellow guards officers, who had deposed her unpopular husband, Peter III, in a bloodless coup accomplished with unexpected ease on the night of 28 June. 'We have ascended the All Russian throne to the acclamation of the whole people and, as the whole world can attest, the former Emperor has himself willingly renounced the throne in a letter written in his own hand.'40 This was a hollow boast. Peter was a.s.sa.s.sinated soon afterwards in circ.u.mstances that still remain mysterious and his death left Catherine exposed as both usurper and a.s.sa.s.sin. Any shred of legitimacy she might possess was vested in her sickly son Paul, still to reach his eighth birthday. As a further complication, Ivan VI, deposed as an infant by Elizabeth in 1741, remained a prisoner in the Schlusselburg fortress, a few miles east of St Petersburg. Remarking on Russia's 'great facility to sudden and dangerous revolutions', This was a hollow boast. Peter was a.s.sa.s.sinated soon afterwards in circ.u.mstances that still remain mysterious and his death left Catherine exposed as both usurper and a.s.sa.s.sin. Any shred of legitimacy she might possess was vested in her sickly son Paul, still to reach his eighth birthday. As a further complication, Ivan VI, deposed as an infant by Elizabeth in 1741, remained a prisoner in the Schlusselburg fortress, a few miles east of St Petersburg. Remarking on Russia's 'great facility to sudden and dangerous revolutions',41 many of Europe's wisest heads predicted that Catherine's coup would be merely a prelude to another in which she herself must surely be overthrown. Barely a week after seizing the throne, she had already resolved that attack remained the best form of defence. On 7 July, the same day that she issued a risible manifesto proclaiming that her murdered husband had perished from an attack of his haemorrhoids, she announced her intention to stage a coronation, on an unspecified date in September, 'in the manner of our former Orthodox Monarchs, and of the pious Greeks [the Byzantine emperors], and of the most ancient Kings of the Israelites, who were customarily anointed with Holy oil'. many of Europe's wisest heads predicted that Catherine's coup would be merely a prelude to another in which she herself must surely be overthrown. Barely a week after seizing the throne, she had already resolved that attack remained the best form of defence. On 7 July, the same day that she issued a risible manifesto proclaiming that her murdered husband had perished from an attack of his haemorrhoids, she announced her intention to stage a coronation, on an unspecified date in September, 'in the manner of our former Orthodox Monarchs, and of the pious Greeks [the Byzantine emperors], and of the most ancient Kings of the Israelites, who were customarily anointed with Holy oil'.42 Here, it seemed, was a cla.s.sic case in which the need for a ritual celebration of the crown's legitimacy had increased as the stability of the state became less certain.43 Yet Catherine was undoubtedly playing for high stakes in holding the coronation so soon after her coup. Some of her most influential supporters, headed by Paul's tutor, Count Nikita Panin, had expected her to rule as regent for her son, and no Russian regent had yet been crowned. Yet Catherine was undoubtedly playing for high stakes in holding the coronation so soon after her coup. Some of her most influential supporters, headed by Paul's tutor, Count Nikita Panin, had expected her to rule as regent for her son, and no Russian regent had yet been crowned.44 The precedents could scarcely have been less encouraging. Tsarevna Sophia, who governed Muscovy on behalf of the boy tsars Ivan V and Peter I from 1682 to 1689, had fatally undermined her authority by campaigning for recognition as ruler in her own right. In The precedents could scarcely have been less encouraging. Tsarevna Sophia, who governed Muscovy on behalf of the boy tsars Ivan V and Peter I from 1682 to 1689, had fatally undermined her authority by campaigning for recognition as ruler in her own right. In The Antidote The Antidote (1770), a polemical work intended to convince sceptical Europeans of Muscovite achievements, Catherine later claimed that Sophia had 'not been given the credit she deserves': 'She conducted the affairs of the Empire for a number of years with all the sagacity that one could hope for.' But the empress can hardly have relished the prospect of ending her life under house-arrest in a convent, the fate that befell Sophia following the coup that installed Peter the Great as de facto sole ruler. (1770), a polemical work intended to convince sceptical Europeans of Muscovite achievements, Catherine later claimed that Sophia had 'not been given the credit she deserves': 'She conducted the affairs of the Empire for a number of years with all the sagacity that one could hope for.' But the empress can hardly have relished the prospect of ending her life under house-arrest in a convent, the fate that befell Sophia following the coup that installed Peter the Great as de facto sole ruler.45 In principle, there was no need to hurry: nowhere in Europe was the interval between accession and coronation prescribed, and Louis XIV, given pause by n.o.ble unrest during the Fronde, had set a French record by waiting eleven years before staging his in 1654. In principle, there was no need to hurry: nowhere in Europe was the interval between accession and coronation prescribed, and Louis XIV, given pause by n.o.ble unrest during the Fronde, had set a French record by waiting eleven years before staging his in 1654.46 Yet the fate of Peter III warned Catherine against delay. By putting off his coronation on the grounds that the regalia were not yet ready, her husband had merely advertised the contempt for Orthodox tradition that contributed to his downfall. Determined to learn from his mistakes, Catherine, as a hostile French diplomat reported in early October, missed 'no opportunity to convey to her people a great idea of her profound piety and devotion to the Greek religion'. Yet the fate of Peter III warned Catherine against delay. By putting off his coronation on the grounds that the regalia were not yet ready, her husband had merely advertised the contempt for Orthodox tradition that contributed to his downfall. Determined to learn from his mistakes, Catherine, as a hostile French diplomat reported in early October, missed 'no opportunity to convey to her people a great idea of her profound piety and devotion to the Greek religion'.47 The vision of Peter III's strangled corpse was not the only violent image that might have flashed across the empress's mind as she descended a flight of stairs that had borne silent witness to some of the bloodiest scenes in Russian history. A reference in her memoirs to the 'famous' Red Staircase suggests that tales of the Moscow rebellion that brought Sophia to power in May 1682 might have been part of the folklore she learned from her pious lady-in-waiting, Praskovya Vladislavova ('that woman was a living archive who knew the scandalous history of every family in Russia from the time of Peter the Great and beyond').48 It was then that the boyar Artamon Matveyev, once the leading minister to Tsar Aleksey Mikhailovich (164576), had allegedly been hurled from the top of the stairs onto the pikes of the mutinous musketeers. Reformed into new regiments by Peter the Great, the Guards had been guarantors of the Russian throne ever since. Conscious that resentment of her relations.h.i.+p with Orlov extended even to supporters of her own coup, Catherine knew as she gazed down on the serried ranks of extravagantly plumed helmets that it would take only one treacherous officer to ignite a riot. The threat was real enough: not long after the coronation, some fifteen guardsmen were arrested and tortured on suspicion of a conspiracy to dethrone her in favour of Ivan VI. It was then that the boyar Artamon Matveyev, once the leading minister to Tsar Aleksey Mikhailovich (164576), had allegedly been hurled from the top of the stairs onto the pikes of the mutinous musketeers. Reformed into new regiments by Peter the Great, the Guards had been guarantors of the Russian throne ever since. Conscious that resentment of her relations.h.i.+p with Orlov extended even to supporters of her own coup, Catherine knew as she gazed down on the serried ranks of extravagantly plumed helmets that it would take only one treacherous officer to ignite a riot. The threat was real enough: not long after the coronation, some fifteen guardsmen were arrested and tortured on suspicion of a conspiracy to dethrone her in favour of Ivan VI.49 On the morning of 22 September, however, all remained tranquil as the crowd waited patiently in silencea sign not of popular disapproval, as it would have been in France, but rather of awed antic.i.p.ation, as the official record of the coronation was anxious to stress. On the morning of 22 September, however, all remained tranquil as the crowd waited patiently in silencea sign not of popular disapproval, as it would have been in France, but rather of awed antic.i.p.ation, as the official record of the coronation was anxious to stress.50

Seeking to invent a myth of legitimacy for the new empress, Catherine's supporters set out to demonstrate the parallels between her and Elizabeth, and beyond Elizabeth to her father, Peter the Great. 'Elizabeth has risen for our sakes,' proclaimed Mikhailo Lomonosov in his 'Ode on the Accession of Catherine II': 'Catherine is the unity of both!'51 To drive home the a.n.a.logy, artists painted Catherine in poses already familiar from portraits of Elizabeth. To ensure that the new empress's coronation followed the same format as Elizabeth's twenty years earlier, Trubetskoy refreshed his memory of that event by researching the historical precedents. To drive home the a.n.a.logy, artists painted Catherine in poses already familiar from portraits of Elizabeth. To ensure that the new empress's coronation followed the same format as Elizabeth's twenty years earlier, Trubetskoy refreshed his memory of that event by researching the historical precedents.52 Even as Catherine's procession made its stately progress towards the Cathedral of the Dormition, her leading supporters offered a visible representation of continuity among Russia's governing elite. Even as Catherine's procession made its stately progress towards the Cathedral of the Dormition, her leading supporters offered a visible representation of continuity among Russia's governing elite.

Although that elite served the tsar in a variety of military and bureaucratic organisations, their inst.i.tutional hierarchies were then overlaid (as they have been ever since in Russia) by a network of informal patronage groups too flexible to be cla.s.sed as factions. By marrying into the Romanov dynasty, the Saltykovs and the Naryshkins, themselves related by marriage to the Trubetskoys, had cornered an increasing number of leading offices since the reign of Peter the Great.53 So it is no surprise to find Peter Naryshkin among the gentlemen-in-waiting carrying the empress's train and Lev Naryshkin among her closest friends. The imperial mantle was entrusted to Field Marshal Peter Saltykov, a hero of the Seven Years' War whom Catherine admired as 'a very good man, active and full of good sense'. So it is no surprise to find Peter Naryshkin among the gentlemen-in-waiting carrying the empress's train and Lev Naryshkin among her closest friends. The imperial mantle was entrusted to Field Marshal Peter Saltykov, a hero of the Seven Years' War whom Catherine admired as 'a very good man, active and full of good sense'.54 She made him Governor General of Moscow. The state sword, first used in 1742, was carried by the Master of the Horse, Peter Sumarokov, whose service in the Senate stretched back to Anna's reign in the 1730s. Admiral Ivan Talyzin, who had ridden out into Cathedral Square to shower coins over the populace at Elizabeth's coronation, now carried the state seal. She made him Governor General of Moscow. The state sword, first used in 1742, was carried by the Master of the Horse, Peter Sumarokov, whose service in the Senate stretched back to Anna's reign in the 1730s. Admiral Ivan Talyzin, who had ridden out into Cathedral Square to shower coins over the populace at Elizabeth's coronation, now carried the state seal.55 During Catherine's coup at the end of June, he had been responsible for turning away the deposed Peter III from the island fortress of Kronstadt. The crown itself was borne by Aleksey Razumovsky, a Ukrainian of Cossack extraction whom Elizabeth had promoted as her Grand Master of the Hunt after plucking him from the choir loft to become her lover thirty years earlier. In his case, lineage was less important than loyalty, and no one was more loyal to Catherine than Count Aleksey Petrovich Bestuzhev-Ryumin. Having initially opposed her invitation to Russia in 1744, Bestuzhev had been arrested fourteen years later as one of her most faithful supporters. Now, 'debauched, profligate, deceitful and interested to excess', During Catherine's coup at the end of June, he had been responsible for turning away the deposed Peter III from the island fortress of Kronstadt. The crown itself was borne by Aleksey Razumovsky, a Ukrainian of Cossack extraction whom Elizabeth had promoted as her Grand Master of the Hunt after plucking him from the choir loft to become her lover thirty years earlier. In his case, lineage was less important than loyalty, and no one was more loyal to Catherine than Count Aleksey Petrovich Bestuzhev-Ryumin. Having initially opposed her invitation to Russia in 1744, Bestuzhev had been arrested fourteen years later as one of her most faithful supporters. Now, 'debauched, profligate, deceitful and interested to excess',56 the old man was about to enjoy a brief Indian summer. the old man was about to enjoy a brief Indian summer.

Waiting to greet her at the south portal of the cathedral, Archbishop Dimitry imparted a vital sense of authority to the whole proceedings. At the beginning of the nineteenth century, the story circulated that he made Catherine tremble by inquiring severely, 'Why have you come?'57 In reality, however, there could hardly have been a more rea.s.suring figure for the empress to meet at the start of a ritual intended to symbolise the harmony of the earthly and the celestial sphereshe had been rewarded for his support during her coup with the personal grant of 1000 serfs. In reality, however, there could hardly have been a more rea.s.suring figure for the empress to meet at the start of a ritual intended to symbolise the harmony of the earthly and the celestial sphereshe had been rewarded for his support during her coup with the personal grant of 1000 serfs.58 Surrounded by no fewer than twenty bishops, thirty-five archimandrites and a host of lesser clergy resplendent in their finest vestments, Catherine kissed the life-giving cross, believed to be studded with a fragment from Christ's crucifix, and followed Dimitry and Metropolitan Timofey past the ma.s.sive, copper-plated doors into an aesthetic world that, for all her professions of loyalty to the Orthodox faith, she never fully understood. Surrounded by no fewer than twenty bishops, thirty-five archimandrites and a host of lesser clergy resplendent in their finest vestments, Catherine kissed the life-giving cross, believed to be studded with a fragment from Christ's crucifix, and followed Dimitry and Metropolitan Timofey past the ma.s.sive, copper-plated doors into an aesthetic world that, for all her professions of loyalty to the Orthodox faith, she never fully understood.

Already installed on tiered benches erected between the cathedral's four great internal pillars was a select congregation of Court ladies, native dignitaries and foreign diplomats who had not taken part in the procession and had, as usual, been left uncertain about the arrangements until the last moment. Like the others, the French amba.s.sador received his invitation only on 20 September, after frantic negotiations about precedence in the seating plan: 'There was nothing they could have done to persuade me to appear at the coronation as a gawping tourist.'59 Facing the altar, in a gallery in front of the west wall, the diplomats occupied the first row with the Baltic n.o.bility behind them, brigadiers in the third row and the Baltic merchants at the back. Female guests sat along the north wall, ranged according to rank behind Countess Anna Vorontsova, and the empress's ladies and maids of honour. Opposite them was a gallery for the foremost Russian officials. Holders of the first three ranks on the Table decreed by Peter the Great in 1722 sat at the front with lesser-ranking bureaucrats further back. Facing the altar, in a gallery in front of the west wall, the diplomats occupied the first row with the Baltic n.o.bility behind them, brigadiers in the third row and the Baltic merchants at the back. Female guests sat along the north wall, ranged according to rank behind Countess Anna Vorontsova, and the empress's ladies and maids of honour. Opposite them was a gallery for the foremost Russian officials. Holders of the first three ranks on the Table decreed by Peter the Great in 1722 sat at the front with lesser-ranking bureaucrats further back.60 At the heart of the cathedral, within full view of all three stands, twelve steps led up to a dais, six feet high, fourteen feet long and five and a half feet wide, draped in red velvet and surrounded by bal.u.s.trades carved with gilded hieroglyphs. Catherine's throne had been sent from Persia for Tsar Boris G.o.dunov at the end of the sixteenth century. To its right stood a gilded table for her regalia; to the left was a place for the young tsarevich. Above the throne, a huge velvet canopy, decorated with gold braid and fringed with lace, was suspended from the ceiling by a chain, joined to each corner by silken ropes in the shape of a pyramid. Into the lining of this canopy was sewn the imperial coat of arms, so that the empress, should she glance to the heavens during her coronation, would stare straight into the eyes of a double-headed eagle.61 By combining his knowledge of Renaissance engineering with rare sensitivity to Russian tradition, Fioravanti had created a building whose conventional exterior, modelled on the twelfth-century Cathedral of the Dormition in Vladimir, concealed one of the lightest and most s.p.a.cious interiors in the Orthodox world. Yet it was by no means so cavernous as it was made to seem in the commemorative ill.u.s.trations of Catherine's coronation by Jean-Louis de Veilly, a French artist who had had a chequered career since arriving in St Petersburg from England in 1754. (His appointment to teach at the Academy of Fine Arts was terminated 'thanks to the peculiarities of his character' and the figures he painted on the floor of the Chinese Room at Tsarskoye Selo seemed 'flushed and somehow drunken because of their slitty eyes'.62) De Veilly evidently used ill.u.s.trations of the Bourbon coronations as one of his models. But even had the Orthodox Church permitted the use of musical instruments to accompany the liturgy, there would scarcely have been room for the 100-piece orchestra hidden behind the altar at Reims for the coronation of Louis XVI in 1775.63 Barely a quarter of the size of Reims or Westminster Abbey, and much more intimate in atmosphere, the Dormition Cathedral had only limited s.p.a.ce for guests. Compet.i.tion for places was intensified by two eighteenth-century developments: the expansion of the n.o.ble elite and Peter the Great's insistence that both s.e.xes should attend Court ceremonials in a church conceived by its Muscovite founders as a strictly male preserve. Barely a quarter of the size of Reims or Westminster Abbey, and much more intimate in atmosphere, the Dormition Cathedral had only limited s.p.a.ce for guests. Compet.i.tion for places was intensified by two eighteenth-century developments: the expansion of the n.o.ble elite and Peter the Great's insistence that both s.e.xes should attend Court ceremonials in a church conceived by its Muscovite founders as a strictly male preserve.

Catherine's nineteen-year-old friend, Princess Dashkova, who might have expected to benefit from the new dispensations, was mortified to discover that instead they militated against her. Having travelled from St Petersburg in the empress's own carriage, Dashkova found that her members.h.i.+p of the Order of St Catherine, to which only thirteen candidates had been appointed during Elizabeth's twenty-year reign, counted for nothing at a ceremony where precedence depended on rank alone. As the wife of a mere colonel, the most junior officer admitted to the coronation, the princess was relegated to the back of the stand, even though her husband, as one of the two masters of ceremonies, had the honour of leading the procession of the imperial regalia from the Senate Palace, where they had been stored overnight, to the Palace of Facets.64 The slight still rankled when Dashkova came to write her self-serving memoirs in 1804. Blaming her humiliation on the Orlovs, who distrusted her as the younger sister of Peter III's disgraced mistress, Elizabeth Vorontsova, she was forced to swallow her pride or absent herself altogether, as friends advised her to do. There was never really a choice. 'I said to myself that if they were putting on an opera I wanted to see and the only seats were in the G.o.ds, then I should, as a pa.s.sionate music-lover, take my place there rather than miss the performance.' The slight still rankled when Dashkova came to write her self-serving memoirs in 1804. Blaming her humiliation on the Orlovs, who distrusted her as the younger sister of Peter III's disgraced mistress, Elizabeth Vorontsova, she was forced to swallow her pride or absent herself altogether, as friends advised her to do. There was never really a choice. 'I said to myself that if they were putting on an opera I wanted to see and the only seats were in the G.o.ds, then I should, as a pa.s.sionate music-lover, take my place there rather than miss the performance.'65

Catherine's coronation was a performance in three acts, of which the first was purely liturgical. As the empress processed to kiss the icons before taking her seat on the throne, the choir chanted Psalm 101 from their specially constructed stalls to the side of the holy gates: 'I will sing of mercy and judgement: unto thee, O Lord, will I sing.'66 By the time they reached King David's final menacing verse'I will early destroy all the wicked of the land; that I may cut off all wicked doers from the city of the Lord'there had been plenty of time for the congregation to contemplate the frescoes of the Last Judgement on the west wall. Though many of these masterpieces had been damaged by condensationCatherine herself later paid for their renovation in the early 1770s By the time they reached King David's final menacing verse'I will early destroy all the wicked of the land; that I may cut off all wicked doers from the city of the Lord'there had been plenty of time for the congregation to contemplate the frescoes of the Last Judgement on the west wall. Though many of these masterpieces had been damaged by condensationCatherine herself later paid for their renovation in the early 1770s67their message was given added urgency in a cathedral built at a time when many Muscovites antic.i.p.ated the imminent end of the world in 1492 (the year 7000 according to the Byzantine calendar numbered from the Creation).68 Now that fears of the Apocalypse had subsided, Catherine's courtiers were less inclined to dwell on divine punishment than on the rewards to be antic.i.p.ated by the righteous. Though the empress may privately have mocked superst.i.tion, the overwhelming majority of her subjects, including many of the most eminent, never abandoned their belief in the power of icons and relics to cure all manner of afflictions. As the most important church in Muscovy, the Cathedral of the Dormition housed some of Orthodoxy's most precious relics, including the head of John Chrysostom, the right hand of the apostle Andrew, one of Basil the Great's fingers, part of a leg of St John the Baptist, and the remains of many lesser, local saints. Now that fears of the Apocalypse had subsided, Catherine's courtiers were less inclined to dwell on divine punishment than on the rewards to be antic.i.p.ated by the righteous. Though the empress may privately have mocked superst.i.tion, the overwhelming majority of her subjects, including many of the most eminent, never abandoned their belief in the power of icons and relics to cure all manner of afflictions. As the most important church in Muscovy, the Cathedral of the Dormition housed some of Orthodoxy's most precious relics, including the head of John Chrysostom, the right hand of the apostle Andrew, one of Basil the Great's fingers, part of a leg of St John the Baptist, and the remains of many lesser, local saints.69 It mattered that the cathedral also contained the most famous miracle-working image in all Russia, the icon of Our Lady of Vladimir, because it had become an established literary convention to a.s.sociate female Russian monarchs with the Virgin Mary. In sharp contrast to St Petersburg, Marian imagery was prominent all over Moscow, which claimed to have inherited the Virgin's traditional role as protectress of Constantinople when the 'second Rome' fell to the Turks in 1453. (The church now famous as St Basil's Cathedral at the southern end o