A History of The Inquisition of The Middle Ages Volume I Part 25

[17] Concil. Lateran. III. ann. 1179 c. 13, 14; IV. ann. 1215 c.

29.--Innocent. PP. III. Regest. I. 82, 191, 471.--P. Cantor. Verb.

abbrev. cap. 31, 32, 34. 80.--Honor. PP. III. Epist. ad Archiep.

Bituricens. ann. 1219.--Urbani. PP. V. Const.i.t. 1367 (Harduin. Concil.

VII. 1767).--Isambert. Anc. Loix Franc. I. 252.--Matt. Paris. Hist.

Angl. ann. 1246 (Ed. 1644 p. 483)--Wadding. Annal. Minor, ann. 1238, No.

8.--D'Argentre, Collect. Judicior. de Nov. Error. I. I. 143.

The correspondence of the papal chancery under Innocent IV., as preserved in the official register, for the first three months of 1245, embraces three hundred and thirty-two letters, and of these about one fifth are dispensations to sixty-five persons to hold pluralities (Berger, Registres d'Innoc. IV. t. I.). A considerable proportion of the remainder are licenses for violations of canon law, showing how exhaustless were the vices of the clergy as a source of profit to the curia. For the rapacity with which the benefices of the dying were sought and disputed, see ibid. No. 1611.

[18] Clement. PP. IV. Epist. 456. (Martene Thesaur. II. 461).--Alcuini Epist. i. ad Arnon. Salisburg. (Pez Thesaur. II. i. 4).--Decreti P. II.

Caus. XIII. Gratiani Comment, in Q. I. cap. i; Caus. XVI. Q. i. cap. 42, 43, 45-47, 56, 57; Caus. XVI. Q. vii. cap. 1-8.--Extra Lib. III. t.i.t.

x.x.x.--Concil. Rotomag. ann. 1189 c. 23.--Concil. Wigorn. ann. 1240 c.

44, 45.--Concil Mertonens. ann. 1300.--Concil. apud Pennam Fidelem ann.

1302 c. 7.--Concil. Maghfeldens. ann. 1332.--Concil. Londin. ann. 1342 c. 4, 5.--Concil. Nimociens. ann. 1298 c. 16.--Concil. Nicosiens. ann.

1340 c. 1.--Concil. Marciac. ann. 1326 c. 30.--Concil. Vaurens. ann.

1368 c. 68-70.--Gerhohi Reichersperg. Lib. de aedificio Dei c. 46.

[19] Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. iii. cap. 40, 41.--Hist.

Monast. S. Laurent. Leodiens. Lib. v. cap. 39.--Innocent. PP. III.

Regest. I. 220; II. 104.--Pet. Cantor. Verb. abbrev. cap. 27-29, 38-40.--Grandjean, Registre de Benoit XI. No. 975.--Concil. Lateran. IV.

ann. 1215, c. 63-66.--Concil. Rotomag. ann. 1231, c. 14.--Teulet, Layettes II. 306, No. 2428.--Const. Provin. S. Edmund. Cantuar. ann.

1236, c. 8.--Synod. Wigorn. ann. 1240, c. 16, 26, 29.--Concil. Turon.

ann. 1239, c. 4, 17.

[20] Synod. Andegav. ann. 1294, c. 3.--Capit. Car. Mag. II. ann. 811, cap. 5.--Concil. Cabillon. II. ann. 813, c. 6.--Concil. Turonens. III.

ann. 813, c. 51.--Concil. Remens. ann. 813.--Concil. Mogunt. ann. 813, c. 6.--Can. 10, Extra Lib. III. t.i.t. xxvi.--Concil. Narbonn. ann. 1227, c. 5.--Concil. Tolosan. ann. 1228, c. 5; ann. 1229, c. 16.--Concil.

Rotomag. ann. 1231. c. 23.--Concil. Arelatens. ann. 1234, c. 21; ann.

1275, c. 8.--Const.i.t. Provin. S. Edmund. Cantuar. ann. 1236, c.

33.--Concil. Albiens. ann. 1254, c. 11.--Concil. Andegav. ann. 1206; 1300.--Respons. Episc. Carca.s.sonn. ann. 1275 (Martene Thesaur. I.

1151).--Concil. Nemausiens. ann. 1284, c. 8.--Concil. Reatinens. ann.

1303, c. 8.--Concil. Cameracens. ann. 1317.

[21] Decreti. II. Caus. xiii. Q. 2.--Can. 1-10, s.e.xto Lib. III. t.i.t.

xxviii.--Anon Zwetlens. Hist. Rom. Pontif. No. 155 (Pez Thesaur. I. iii.

383).--Narrat. Restaur. Abbat. S. Martini Tornacens. cap. 86-89.--Synod.

Wigorn. ann. 1240, c. 50.--Ripoll Bullar. Ord. Praedic. VII.

5.--Grandjean, Registre de Benoit XI. No. 974.--Innocent. PP. III.

Regest. VII. 165.--G.B. de Lagreze, La Navarre, t. II. p. 165.--Concil.

Avenion. ann. 1326, c. 27; ann. 1237, c. 32.--Teulet, Layettes II. 306, No. 2428.--Concil. Nimociens. ann. 1296, c. 17.--Const.i.t. Joann. Arch.

Nicosiens. ann. 1321, c. 10.--Concil. Vaurens. ann. 1368, c. 63, 64.

[22] Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. III. cap. 27.--P. Cantor.

Verb. abbrev. cap. 138.--Lowenfeld Epistt. Pont. Rom. ined. No. 92, 114 (Lipsiae, 1885).--See the Author's "Historical Sketch of Sacerdotal Celibacy," 2d edition, 1884.

[23] Stephani Tornacens. Epist. XII.--Innocent. PP. III. Regest. VI.

183; VIII. 192-193; X. 209-210, 215; XV. 202. For the subsequent career of Waldemar of Sleswick, see Regest. XI. 10, 173; XII. 63; XIII. 158; XV. 3; Supplement. 187, 224, 228, 243. Cf. Arnold. Lubecens. VI. 18; VII. 12, 13; and Vaissette, Hist. Gen. de Languedoc, IV. 80 (ed. 1742).

For details of clerical immunity, see the author's "Studies in Church History," 2d edition, 1883.

[24] Concil. ap. Campinac.u.m ann. 1238, c. 1, 6.

[25] Varior. ad Alex. PP. III. Epist. XCV. (Migne, Patrolog. CC. 1457).

Cf. Pet. Blesens. Epist. XC.--Innocent. PP. III. Regest. I. 386, 476, 483, 499; V. 159; VIII. 12; IX. 209; XIII. 132; XV. 105.--Pet. Cantor.

Verb. abbrev. cap. 44.--Gerhohi Lib. de aedificio Dei cap. 33; Ejusd.

Exposit. in Psalm. lxiv. cap. 35.--Chron. S. Trudon. Libb. III., IV., V.--Hist. Vezeliacens. Libb. II.-IV.--Chron. Senoniens. Libb. IV., V.--Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. IV. cap. 65-67. For ample details as to the immorality of the monasteries, see the author's "History of Celibacy."

[26] Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. I. cap. 3, 24, 31.--Hist Monast. Andaginens. cap. 34.

[27] Gregor. PP. I. Dialog. IV. 55.--D'Achery Spicileg. III.

382.--Chron. S. Trudon. Lib. VI.

[28] Augustin. de Op. Monachor. ii. 3.--Ca.s.siani. de Cn.o.b. Inst.i.t. ii.

3.--Hieron. Epistt. x.x.xIX.; CXXV. 16.--Regul. S. Benedicti. cap. 1.--S.

Isidor. Hispal. de Eccles. Offic. II. xvi. 3, 7.--Ludov. Pii de Reform.

Eccles. cap. 100.--Smaragd. Comment. in Regul. Benedict. c. 1.--Ripoll Bull. Ord. FF. Praedic. I. 38.--Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. VI.

cap. 20.--Catalog. Varior. Haereticor. (Bib. Max. Patrum. Ed. 1618, t.

XIII. p. 309).

[29] Brevis Hist. Prior. Grandimont.--Stephani Tornacens. Epistt. 115, 152, 153, 156, 162.

Prior Peter's fear that the convent would be converted into a market-place and a fair is ill.u.s.trated by the complaint of the Council of Beziers in 1233, that many religious houses were in the habit of retailing their wine within the sacred enclosure, and attracting consumers by having jugglers, actors, gamblers, and strumpets there.--Concil. Biterrens. ann. 1233, c. 23.

[30] Giberti Gemblac. Epistt. v. vi.

[31] Petri Exoniens. Summ. Exigendi Confess. ann. 1287 (Harduin. VII.

1128).--Caesar. Heisterbac. Dial. Mirac. Dist. III. cap. 45.--Martene Ampliss. Coll. I. 357.

[32] P. Damiani Opusc. V.--Concil. Trident. Sess. vi. Decret. de Justific. c. 16, 30.--Migne, Encyclopedic Theologique. t. XXVII. pp.

59-63, 118.--Abaelardi Ethica, cap. 25.--Cap. 14 Extra Lib. v. t.i.t.

iii.--Concil. Lateran. IV. c. 72.--Alani de Insulis contra Haeret. Lib.

II. cap. xi.--Gregor. PP. IX. Bull. 29 Apr. 1228; 18 Jul. 1237 (Potthast Regesta, I. 705, 884).--Addis and Arnold's Catholic Dict. s. v.

_Portiuncula_.--Lib. Conformitatum S. Fran. Lib. II. tract. ii. (fol.

135-138. Ed. 1513).--Bonifacii PP. VIII. Bull. _Antiquorum habet_.--Concil. Claromont. ann. 1195, c. 2.--Urbani PP. II. Synodalis Concio.--Concil. Lateran. IV. can. ult.--Le Grand d'Aussy, Fabliaux, I.

379, 392.--Prediche del B. Fra Giordano da Rivalto (Firenze, 1831, I.

253).--Nicolai PP. IV. Bull. _Illuminit_, ann. 1291.--Gregor. PP. XI.

Bull. _Dudum_, 23 Apr. 1372.

The mediaeval doctrine of indulgence is truly expressed by Alonso, Bishop of Avila, in 1443, when disculpating himself to Eugenius IV. from an accusation of doubting the papal power: "Papa etiam potest absolvere ab omnibus peccatis et potest dare plenariam indulgentiam, liberando homine a tota pna Purgatorii, scilicet faciendo quod non veniet in illum etiamsi multa pna (peccata) commiserit" (D'Argentre, Collect. Judic. de novis Error. I. ii. 241). Yet when an enthusiastic Franciscan taught at Tournay, in 1482, that the pope at will could empty purgatory, the University of Paris qualified the proposition as doubtful and scandalous (Ibid. I. ii. 305). The same year the University again interfered, when the church of Saintes, having procured a bull of indulgence from Sixtus IV., announced publicly that, no matter how long a period of punishment had been a.s.signed by divine justice to a soul, it would fly from purgatory to heaven as soon as three sols were paid in its behalf to be expended in repairing the church (Ibid. 307). In 1518 the university was obliged to repeat its condemnation of the same promises made to those who would contribute a _teston_ for the crusade which was always under way and never attempted (Ib. 355). Yet the doctrine thus condemned by the university was p.r.o.nounced to be unquestionable Catholic truth by the Dominican Silvestro Mozzolino, in his refutation of Luther's Theses, dedicated to Leo X. (F. Silvest. Prieriatis Dialogus, No. 27). As Silvestro was made general of his order and master of the sacred palace, it is evident that no exceptions to his teaching were taken at Rome.

Those who doubt that the abuses of the system were the proximate cause of the Reformation can consult Van Espen, Jur. Eccles. Universi P. II.

t.i.t. vii. cap. 3 No. 9-12. Cf. Ibid. P. II. t.i.t. x.x.xvii. cap. 6 No.

43-46, for their continuance into the eighteenth century.

The modern commercial spirit has not failed to take advantage of the indulgence. The Libreria Religiosa of Barcelona is enabled to advertise that various Spanish prelates have granted an indulgence of 2320 days (fifty-eight quarantaines) to every one who will read or hear read a chapter or even a single page of any of its publications.

[33] Concil. Turon. ann. 1236, c. 1.--etabliss.e.m.e.nts de S. Louis, Liv.

i. cap. 84.--Berger, Les Registres d'Innocent IV. No. 2230.

[34] Matt. Paris. Hist. Angl. ann. 1251 (p. 553, Ed. 1644).--Chron.

Turon. ann. 1226.--Joannis PP. XXII. Regest. IV. 73, 74, 76, 77, 95, 97, 99.--Baluz. et Mansi Miscell. III. 242.--Concil. Ravennat. ann. 1314, c.